Summary Judgment for Hospital Re: Domestic Abuse

By Curtis Jones

In McSwane v. Bloomington Hospital and Healthcare System, No. 53S04-0808-CV-420, (Ind. Nov. 30, 2009), the Indiana Supreme Court in a 3-2 decision affirmed summary judgment for a hospital against charges alleging breach of duty when it permitted an individual to leave the hospital with a suspected domestic abuser.  Shortly after leaving the hospital the suspected abuser murdered the former hospital patient, and then took his own life.  The victim’s estate sued the hospital.

The Court initially noted: “While the existence of a duty is regarded as a matter of law, summary judgment based on application of law to particular facts is rarely suitable.”  In McSwane, the Court found the facts to be “suitable.”  The Court noted that ” a hospital’s duty of care to a patient who presents observable signs of domestic abuse includes some reasonable measures to address the patient’s risk.”  The measures in this case included:  direct suggestions to the patient that abuse might be the cause of her injuries, providing a chance to indicate abuse outside the earshot of the abuser, security examinations of the suspected abuser, calling and notifying law enforcement and advising the patient that she need not leave the hospital with the suspected abuser.

In Dissent, two Justices opined that this issue of duty should have been decided by a jury – not on summary judgment.  Interestingly, the Court’s majority opinion stated that this case could be “analyzed by asking whether the hospital, construing the facts favorably to McSwane, has succeeded in demonstrating that it did not breach its duty, a burden rarely but occasionally met as a matter of law.”  (emphasis added).  In sum, this case was “factually” close and only in time will we learn whether it will become controlling precedent or factually distinguished.

About Curtis T. Jones

Curtis Jones (CUJO) is a Partner in the Appellate, Litigation and Insurance Groups at Bose McKinney & Evans LLP (BME). ~Before joining BME, I served for two years as a judicial law clerk for the Honorable Theodore (Ted) R. Boehm in the Supreme Court of Indiana. Since 2006, I have worked extensively on a number of complex business and commercial litigation matters and have handled numerous appeals in the Indiana Appellate Courts and Seventh Circuit. I have also assisted insurers, wholesalers, agents, brokers and insureds in the insurance industry analyze, litigate and/or resolve coverage issues.~ For more information about Curtis T. Jones:
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s