Peg Zaremba appeals the trial court’s dismissal with prejudice of her claim against Jessica Nevarez and John Nevarez for rent and damages. Zaremba raises two issues, which we consolidate and restate as whether the trial court abused its discretion by denying Zaremba’s motion to correct error concerning the trial court’s dismissal with prejudice of Zaremba’s complaint. Zaremba argues that the trial court abused its discretion when it: (A) determined that a previous dismissal without prejudice could serve as res judicata for a subsequent refiling of the same claim; and (B) stated that a plaintiff who fails to appear on time for trial in a small claims case was required to seek relief pursuant to Ind. Trial Rule 60.
Conclusion (slip op. at 11): We reverse the trial court‟s dismissal of Zaremba’s claim against the Nevarezes and remand for proceedings consistent with this opinion.
Key Analysis (slip op. at 6, 10): For principles of res judicata to apply, there must have been a final judgment on the merits and that judgment must have been entered by a court of competent jurisdiction . . . Because [the previous cause] was dismissed without prejudice, it was not a judgment on the merits . . . Small Claims Rule 10 is specific and “[d]ismissal with prejudice is contemplated only when the plaintiff again fails to appear after the claim has been refiled.” Here, the record does not reveal that Zaremba failed to appear after the claim was refiled. Thus, Rule 10(A) does not contemplate dismissal with prejudice under the circumstances.
DisclaimerADVERTISING MATERIAL www.boselaw.com/disclaimer
- Amish Litigants Forced to Honor Agreement
- Indiana Appellate Civil Case Law Summary (May 2012)
- U.S. Supreme Court Strikes Down FCC’s Indecency Determinations Against Fox And ABC
- Indiana Appellate Civil Case Law Summary (February 2012)
- Extraordinary Stay Against Newspaper Publication Should Raise Concern
- absolute privilege Advertising Injury Alternative Fee amish anonymous speech Antitrust Appeals Boehm Censorship CERCLA Class Actions Commercial Lines Policy Communications Law Defamation Discovery discovery tools Duty to Defend environmental cleanup FCC First Amendment Free Speech Indecency Indiana indiana court of appeals Indiana Supreme Court Internet Law Journalist's Privilege Justice Life Insurance Media Law Newsgathering objections public utility religious Res Judicata Sevnth Circuit sewer district Shepard Technology United States Supreme Court